So it’s the eve before voting commences where we decide whether or not we as a nation, join the other three countries in the world who use AV aka The Alternative Vote.
This was my first reaction:
What a very liberal approach. It’s like one of those irritating new age teachers you get at school. You’re quite happily thrashing another team in any sport, lets pick Hockey for example, and you beat the other team 10 – 0. You’re happily celebrating with your team when she comes over and announces that you are all winners and both teams win medals.

In almost all kinds of competitions and voting activities, the majority will be disappointed!
What? I hear you cry! They are not winners, your team won, they lost. Simple math! 10 is bigger than 0, always will be. Half of those playing would have been upset, I grant you, but you still do not take away the merit from the other team. If there is nothing to play for, there’s no point in playing! It’s a great lesson for kids and should not be taken away!
Equally, lets look at a race. 10 kids, 100 metres in front of them. 90% of those children are going to be disappointed. Each child has two supporters, their mum and dad. I’m keeping it simple, I know this is not an average family in modern-day Britain. Therefore 90% of the audience are going to be disappointed and would have been rooting for a child who did not win. Surely that’s not fair? More people lost than won!
YES, BECAUSE IT’S A RACE FOR CHRIST SAKE!
With AV you still have one winner but you don’t lose by as much, and it’s a little bit nicer to those who lost as they can get a couple more votes- oh grow up!
So, yes, this was my initial reaction to AV.
So after having been literally littered with leaflets over the past month, I’ve come to this conclusion about AV and jotted down some good and bad points.
Bad Points of AV:
It’s expensive
It’s complicated (well I understand it, but many don’t)
More hung parliaments (that’s working great so far)
Racist parties have more of a say (BNP for example)
It’s pointless? (as in to say, deal with pressing matters at the current time)
People will vote badly- let me expand.
You Labour supporters who hate Tories for no other reason other than they appear posh, rich and Thatcher-ish, will therefore give Conservative the lowest vote.
Equally, you Tory supporters will only think of Blair’s creepy smile, Gordon’s incompetence, the fall of our great country and Cherie not bowing to the Queen (I mean what was that about?) So you will give Labour the lowest vote.
Now, I dislike one of these parties greatly, and the thought of being petty and putting them bottom appeals most definitely, but I don’t like the fact that BNP could get a higher vote than either of them. But that’s going to happen if this voting system takes place.
My point is that manifesto’s will be less read than they are now, and the only reason on voting would be to try to score the one you hate with the lowest possible vote. It becomes petty and childish. Labour and Conservative are not all different at times on certain policies but some people seem so against either one of these parties that they will give their higher votes to others even if they disagree with a majority of their policies.
Good Points of AV:
Errrm…
Give us a second…
There’s got to be something surely…
I’ll get back to you if I can think of any!